› Forums › Herpes Questions › Assessing risk, F->M, first few months of relationship
- This topic has 1 reply, 2 voices, and was last updated 6 years, 8 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
February 17, 2020 at 2:51 pm #69328AnonymousAnonymousAnonymousParticipant
Hi Terri,
My girlfriend and I (male), upper 40’s both, are talking about starting sex. She’s had “herpes” for many years. (I need to confirm, but let’s assume for now this means HSV-2 genital.)
I’m negative for HSV-1/HSV-2 antibodies. I’m trying to quantify risk of transmission, and identify all reasonable things we can do to prevent it. Then put it out of our minds and enjoy.
You cited the “4% statistic” in your handbook: if the woman has HSV-2 and the man doesn’t, and they avoid sex during (detected) outbreaks, and don’t use condoms/antivirals, and have an “average” sex life… the risk of transmission over one year is 4%. This is one of very few statistics I’ve seen suggesting an absolute expected rate of transmission. 4% isn’t bad.
But the caveat: these participants had been in relationship 1+ years, and yet “most herpes is transmitted in the first three months of a relationship so when couples are enrolled in these trials, they’ve already come through the period in their relationship where transmission is most likely. They are, in essence, herpes survivors. So these transmission statistics should be viewed in that light.”
So before the 4% number has any meaning at all, we must first pass through a high-risk phase where it has none at all. How much higher? Can it be controlled? And it happens to be the phase where I’m least sure about committing to marriage (at which point I care less about getting it). That’s kind of a problem.
So my questions:
* what are the factors making this phase high-risk? Apparently it isn’t just that people are less careful early on (foregoing condoms/antivirals), because the study already assumed they weren’t being used, yet you highlighted we must interpret differently because of it.
* are these factors preventable, if we’re careful? IOW, is 4% still achievable somehow?
* if not, then how much higher risk are we talking about? 3x? 10x? Some bounding would help me feel better about this.Thanks.
-
February 25, 2020 at 9:08 pm #69399Terri WarrenKeymaster
* what are the factors making this phase high-risk? Apparently it isn’t just that people are less careful early on (foregoing condoms/antivirals), because the study already assumed they weren’t being used, yet you highlighted we must interpret differently because of it.
I think one of the things that makes this initial period of sexuality high risk is that people have more sex in the first few months of a new relationship and perhaps longer sexual encounters. Right? And there is no solution to that! We to identify those infected and put them on suppression.
* are these factors preventable, if we’re careful? IOW, is 4% still achievable somehow?
It is – condoms, suppression, identifying those infected to involve them in preventive efforts.
* if not, then how much higher risk are we talking about? 3x? 10x? Some bounding would help me feel better about this.
We don’t know. We don’t have any data except to identify that the first three months of a relationship is the riskiest time frame.
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.