› Forums › Herpes Questions › Confused, positive IGM, negative IGG
- This topic has 7 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 6 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
April 1, 2019 at 4:24 pm #33982Unlucky39Spectator
I am very concerned about recent testing that I had for HSV.
I am a 39 year old gay male.
Two years ago I had a routine STD screening. Everything came back normal except an equivocal HSV IGM index of 1.09. At the time I was not experiencing any symptoms and my doctor informed me of the unreliability of the test at the time. HSV1 IGG was 0.08 and HSV2 IGG was 0.06.
Jump ahead to last week. Monday, during masturbation, I noticed, by sight, not feeling, a small lesion on the shaft of my penis. I figured it was a scratch from my zipper that had occurred earlier in the week, which at the time, I didn’t think would have left a mark. I had applied some triple antiobiotic ointment to it. Friday, I decided to go to the doctor to have it checked out just in case. The PA-C who evaluated me said she did not believe it looked herpatic, that she believed it was a contusion. I asked if we could do a full STD testing, since it was about time for one.
Saturday, I received a notification that some of my test results were available in my healthcare portal. I was shocked to see a positive HSV IGM value of 1.73.
Sunday, I received a notification that my healthcare portal had the IGG results.
HSV1 negative 0.143 and HSV2 negative 0.138.Today, Monday, I still had not heard from the PA-C to discuss results, but did receive a notification on my phone from CVS Pharmacy that an order had been put in for 1 gram of Valtrex twice daily for 14 days.
My only sexual contact in at least the past 2 years was kissing and mutual masturbation with two other males in which we both masturbated each other after touching our own penis. No oral sex, no anal sex. One instance was two months ago, the more recent about 1.5 weeks before noticing the abrasion.
The abrasion on my penis has since scabbed, the scab has fallen off and is just a little red with some dry skin around it.
Any chance this is a false positive on the recent IGM? Does my sexual activity make HSV a concern? Is Valtrex warranted?
-
April 10, 2019 at 10:04 am #34287Terri WarrenKeymaster
There is a HUGE chance the IgM is positive. Shame shame shame on them for running this test – the CDC says never to use it. It’s a money make for labs and nothing more. Your IgG is negative and that’s what matters. Having said that, I am concerned about the lesion on your penis. The IgG misses 30% of HSV 1 and 8% of HSV 2 compared to the gold standard western blot. If you get another of these anywhere on the penis, please have it swab tested right away. If you specifically recall getting your penis caught in your zipper, that is reassuring.
Terri
-
April 10, 2019 at 12:14 pm #34305Unlucky39Spectator
Terri,
Thank you for answering.
I guess my question is – where do I go from here?
I have been abstaining from sexual activity since I got the positive IGM test results.
The abrasion on my penis has healed and looks just slightly discolored as a scar would. No weird sensation at the site.
Despite a negative IGG, but based on the positive IGM my PA-C had me take a week of 1G of Valtrex twice daily and disclose to my known mutual masturbation partner (who is in heterosexual married relationship, this did not go well).
Was the Valtrex warranted?
What is the risk of contracting either HSV1 or HSV2 only from kissing and mutual masturbation? No oral or anal sex has occurred for over 1.5 years?
Should I wait a period of time and retest? If so, which test?
I did have shingles at one point. Could that cause a positive IGM?
What medical specialty handles situations like this as I think my PCP’s office has already made the situation worse by even ordering an IGM?
I still can’t believe I learned about the positive IGM by an automated lab result posting to my portal giving a notification on my iPhone, then getting a notification that Valtrex is ready at the pharmacy before I even knew what was going on – and not hearing from the PA-C for days.
To say that I am beyond stressed about this situation would be an understatement. I do not want to be single forever and would like to have an active sex life. In short, I don’t even know what to say to potential dates/partners – I’m not sure if I have herpes or not.
Any insight would be helpful. Thank you.
-
April 10, 2019 at 12:22 pm #34306Unlucky39Spectator
Also, you say there is a HUGE chance the IGM is positive. What does this mean? What would cause this? Do you mean a false positive?
-
April 11, 2019 at 10:33 am #34333Terri WarrenKeymaster
In my experience, 80-90% of positive IgM tests are false positives. It’s just a very poor test, not something about you personally. It’s clearly picking up something else.
Given your sexual history, I would bet a substantial amount of money that you are not infected. Mutual masturbation is not a method of transmission of HSV.
You could have HSV 1 and the IgG is missing it. It is far less likely to miss an HSV 2 infection.
If you were my patient and you had a genital lesion and negative IgG, I would order a western blot, just to be more certain.
There is absolutely no point in waiting to test again given the timing of your sexual encounters.Terri
-
April 22, 2019 at 1:13 pm #34709Unlucky39Spectator
Terri,
Thank you for answering my questions. The abrasion on my penis has healed and I have had no issues whatsoever since my original post.
I just got back from seeing a dermatology PA-C about this situation. I advised her of my sexual history – no oral, anal, or vaginal sex in at least 1.5 years, and that I had engaged in mutual masturbation twice in the past three months.
The dermatology PA-C said that based on my recent sexual activity (or lack thereof), and negative IGG’s for both HSV1 and HSV2 that she believes strongly that the IGM was a false positive. She stated that she did not believe that repeat testing was warranted as long as I did not show any symptoms in the future. In short, she stated I should go on with my life and not worry about this.
She also stated that she was horrified that another advanced practitioner would even consider ordering and IGM test based on it’s on lack of reliability and potential to cause anxiety in the event of false positives. She advised me to be very upfront about the fact that I do not ever want an IGM test run again. She advised me that if I ever had any questions that I could contact her directly and she would be entirely unbiased and nonjudgmental. This is important to me because I got the sense that there may have been some bias in the way this was handled originally at my PCP‘s office based on the fact that I am gay. Not all of us sleep around. Also, I am extremely careful when I do engage in sexual activity.
I am frustrated that this situation has caused me almost a month of severe anxiety because a test that never should’ve been run was run.
Terri, any thoughts?
Thanks!
-
April 22, 2019 at 1:18 pm #34710Unlucky39Spectator
The dates I mutually masturbated with another male were 1/14/19 and 3/16/19.
-
April 22, 2019 at 2:49 pm #34734Terri WarrenKeymaster
I am in complete agreement with your most recent clinician. Their statements are fully in agreement with my statements to you about the IgM test. Ignore it. My only concern is the genital lesions that you described that scabbed over. If you want the most definitive test about this, it’s the western blot. Or you could just move on. Your call. the IgG is also not a perfect test, as you know.
This is your final post on this subscription. If you have more questions, feel free to renew.
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.