› Forums › Herpes Questions › False Negative?
- This topic has 3 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 8 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
February 24, 2016 at 11:07 pm #12175Ditat_DeusParticipant
Background: Although no culture was done, diagnosed with HSV-2 in 2002 by family physician. Just from eye-balling it. Symptoms were vaginal only: no fever, shoots pains etc. I believed the diagnosis to be true at the time: I had intercourse with a new partner 2 weeks prior. I used OTC yeast infection cream few days after sex and again 2 days prior to office visit. NO outbreaks since diagnosis.
In 2008 (6 years later), I was in a long-term relationship and my HSV-negative partner wanted to have unprotected sex. I started taking 500mg Valtrex (generic) once daily and still do. No tests. Partner never contracted HSV-2.
In 2014 (12 years after diagnosis), I requested a full STD panel, and guess what:
HSV 2 IGG HERPESELECT TYPE SPECIFIC AB Normal
Detail: HSV 2 IGG HERPESELECT – <.90
I went about my life thinking it had to be wrong.A year later at my annual OBGYN checkup, I inquired about the results and was re-tested, which resulted in my 2nd “Normal”. I didn’t ask for specific values but was told, “you have HSV-1, and while I cannot tell you its location, you definitely do not have HSV-2”
Last week, I get a call from a guy I had sex with once in 2012: He tells me I gave him HSV-2. I disclosed info at the time (I thought I had it in 2012) but still feel horrible. Even though I tested negative twice, he’s convinced it’s from me.
1) It’s been 14 years since the diagnosis and I’ve taken Valtrex daily for the past
8 years, can I trust these two negatives? Can you ballpark the impact? (Ex: accuracy would drop from 97% to 50%)2) Technically, I am HSV-2 negative. Ethically, do I disclose that I am positive anyway?
3) I need a clear conscience. I plan to take IGG, biotest, and Western Blot: For the most accurate results, how many days prior to test do I need to stop using Valtrex? What else can I do to ensure accuracy?
4) Anything else I need to know?
Best regards Terri. Cheers!
-
February 26, 2016 at 9:34 am #12183Terri WarrenKeymaster
The guy who claims you gave him HSV 2 is wrong. You didn’t.
1) It’s been 14 years since the diagnosis and I’ve taken Valtrex daily for the past
8 years, can I trust these two negatives? Can you ballpark the impact? (Ex: accuracy would drop from 97% to 50%)Seroreversion (going from positive to negative) has been documented with the IgG test but is really rare, and never happens with the herpes western blot antibody test – you might want to get a western blot to confirm that but I would bet a lot of money that you don’t have HSV 2.
2) Technically, I am HSV-2 negative. Ethically, do I disclose that I am positive anyway?
You do not need to disclose this. that would be incorrect information to share with someone.
3) I need a clear conscience. I plan to take IGG, biotest, and Western Blot: For the most accurate results, how many days prior to test do I need to stop using Valtrex? What else can I do to ensure accuracy?
Do not take all of those tests, just do the western blot. We can order that for you as part of our study (under the “herpes” tab on this website). It is the gold standard and if you are doing that, you don’t need to do anything else.
4) Anything else I need to know?
You need to know that when people are diagnosed by visual exam only with genital herpes, the clinician is wrong 20% of the time, and those are experienced STD clinicians – I shudder to think of the rate with generalists. Also you don’t need to stop antiviral therapy to do the western blot
Terri- This reply was modified 10 years, 8 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
February 26, 2016 at 8:51 pm #12205Ditat_DeusParticipant
Thanks, Terri.
I have a few follow up questions:
1.0) seroreversion: I have never heard this term until now. I googled it, but I’m still unclear on the true meaning. For arguments sake, let’s say I did (or still do) have hsv-2.
1.1) Does testing negative due to seroreversion mean that I am no longer a carrier and cannot transmit the virus? Or does this mean I test negative while still being infected and contagious?
1.2) Is it possible that I had hsv-2, but no longer do? If I did have hsv-2, and now I don’t, would this mean I can be reinfected? Or would this provide immunity?
2.0) I would love to be a part of your study, but I do not want to provide my real name. I’d be happy to answer all questions openly and honestly, but I’ve always been the paranoid type and don’t want to reveal my identity.
2.1) Could I do your study without giving you a name?
2.2) If not, can the WB be done aynonomously through your clinic? Keep in mind I’m 2,000+ miles away.
2.3) How common is cross contamination using the WB?
Cheers.
-
February 27, 2016 at 8:59 am #12212Terri WarrenKeymaster
1.0) seroreversion: I have never heard this term until now. I googled it, but I’m still unclear on the true meaning. For arguments sake, let’s say I did (or still do) have hsv-2.
Seroreversion just means that you were positive on the IgG test and are now negative on the IgG test.
1.1) Does testing negative due to seroreversion mean that I am no longer a carrier and cannot transmit the virus? Or does this mean I test negative while still being infected and contagious?
No, it just means that the test isn’t picking it up now for some reason but I actually seriously doubt that’s what is going on.
1.2) Is it possible that I had hsv-2, but no longer do? If I did have hsv-2, and now I don’t, would this mean I can be reinfected? Or would this provide immunity?
No, if you ever had HSV 2 then you still do – it is a lifelong infection, it does not clear
2.0) I would love to be a part of your study, but I do not want to provide my real name. I’d be happy to answer all questions openly and honestly, but I’ve always been the paranoid type and don’t want to reveal my identity.
We do not ask for any proof of identity with the study at all nor does the lab where you go to have you blood drawn
2.1) Could I do your study without giving you a name?
No, we have to have SOME name, we just don’t have to have your name.
2.2) If not, can the WB be done aynonomously through your clinic? Keep in mind I’m 2,000+ miles away.
We can’t do any lab testing with no name but we can order the study labs to be drawn where you live under some name.
2.3) How common is cross contamination using the WB?
Not at all
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.