› Forums › Herpes Questions › GHSV1 M->F Transmission Rates
- This topic has 3 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 2 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
September 6, 2017 at 3:06 pm #20630leiga614Participant
I am trying to determine what the risk of transmission is for ghsv1. I was recently diagnosed by a swab test after having a very minor initial outbreak. My guess is I received it from unprotected oral sex.
I understand shedding rates are 3-5% but it is hard to find any information beyond that. How do you calculate transmission from shedding rates? 3-5% sounds high…I’ve read on here that transmission rates or low/not-likely, but what is low, 2% or <1%. To me, <1% is low.
I found the post below that seems to suggest there is hardly any risk at all:
http://www.medhelp.org/posts/STDs/Genital-HSV-1-Transmission/show/602074
1. What is the risk of genital -> genital? (condom, no condom), M->F
2. What is the risk of genital -> oral? (unprotected)
3. What are the rates if I am taking suppressants?
4. Condom: a condom covers where I had a single, minor sore. Does that indicate the effectiveness of condoms?
5. The dr. I saw suggested my semen can transmit the virus. Is this true?I saw a dr. and he recommended I wait at least three months to start antivirals, so my body could build up antibodies on its own. That is why I want transmission rates for both being on suppressants and not. He was fairly broad in describing transmission risk, citing 88% chance of not passing it on without condoms/suppressants. He was also reticent to prescribe suppressants for non-recurring ghsv1.
- This topic was modified 9 years, 2 months ago by leiga614.
-
September 7, 2017 at 9:39 am #20651Terri WarrenKeymaster
We have no real study looking at transmission of genital HSV 1 so anything I saw would be a total guess.
I can extrapolate from HSV 2 transmission data, knowing something about shedding rates of both, but again, these are guesses, not science.I would guess the transmission rate from genital to genital would be around 2-3% per year, having sex about twice per week, without a condom and without antivirals. With a condom, very close to zero. The risk from your genitals to someone else’s mouth might be about the same since HSV 1 does like the mouth better but it could be lower. Semen is a very poor transmitter of virus – very poor. It’s skin to skin with few exceptions.
Know that is is possible you’ve had this a long time.
Your body will produce antibody more slowly if you are on suppression but it eventually will – I don’t think it makes much difference if you take it or not in terms of that but it would likely reduce transmission.Terri
-
September 7, 2017 at 11:41 am #20661leiga614Participant
Thanks. A couple of follow-up questions:
I’m not quite sure I understand the following:
“The risk from your genitals to someone else’s mouth might be about the same since HSV 1 does like the mouth better but it could be lower. ”Are you saying the risk is about the same as unprotected genital-genital or higher?
- If I am shedding and wearing a condom, how does transmission work?
- If I am on suppressants, what is your guess at transmission rates for un-protected oral, protected intercourse and unprotected intercourse.
I understand there isn’t much data, but as somebody who is trying to understand how this affects future relations, I’m looking for some level of understanding. To me, getting the risk rate below 1%, compared to 2-3% is a huge difference.
I also don’t quite understand how there aren’t studies currently being done on GHSV1 due to the prevalence of HSV1 and the high rate of new HSV1 cases being GHSV1. While I understand it isn’t life threatening, HSV affects one of the most intimate parts of a persons life and not allocating resources to research such a prevalent disease seems irresponsible and callous.
Unfortunately, I know this is a new infection as I was in a long-term relationship and contracted the infection from either the first or second individual I slept with.
-
September 8, 2017 at 8:02 am #20671Terri WarrenKeymaster
If I am shedding and wearing a condom, how does transmission work?
Condoms reduce transmission of HSV by 96% – huge reduction. Condoms do break or slip off from time to time,however.
If I am on suppressants, what is your guess at transmission rates for un-protected oral, protected intercourse and unprotected intercourse.
I would say the risk for these activities is likely around 1-2% or less without a condom, less with a condom. These are guesses
I understand there isn’t much data, but as somebody who is trying to understand how this affects future relations, I’m looking for some level of understanding. To me, getting the risk rate below 1%, compared to 2-3% is a huge difference.
With the combination of daily antivirals and condoms, I think the risk of transmission via intercourse is likely below 1%.
Studies are being done of HSV 1 – we just don’t have data available yet.
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.