› Forums › Herpes Questions › HSV-1 Clarity of Msg to Partners
- This topic has 5 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 5 years, 4 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
June 5, 2021 at 4:44 pm #73827kindnessmattersParticipant
Hi Terri!
Blood test on STI panel showed HSV-1 pos (HSV-2 Neg). Western Blot confirmed. First STI panel in roughly 15 yrs due to sex Hx, not aware doc chose to test for HSV without symptoms while no other doc I’ve talked to since would have.Now that I have to disclose HSV-1 results, things got complicated with others who will never be tested.
No known symptoms ever & I believe it’s likely from childhood or early on in my current 6.5 yr relationship. I continue to be asymptomatic.
As I have read,we don’t really have much concrete data on HSV-1 risk and transmission. That’s super frustrating, esp. given the prevalence and persistence of this virus considered an STI.
I’ve read that HSV-1 risk is less than HSV-2, we just don’t know how much. Open to what you might think with this strategy as a way to educate potential partners on HSV-1, and to have as close as I can get to concrete data for myself.
Does this math add up? Assuming no active infection
-If HSV-2 risk is 10% m2f, 4% f2m, HSV-1 risk lower (does this data assume outbreaks happen or asymptomatic?)
-HSV-2 on antivirals reduces risk by 50-70%, so at highest, 5% / 2% risk, at lowest, 3% / 1.2% risk
-HSV-2 with condoms reduces risk by 96% / 60-65%, so .4% m2f / 1.6-1.4% f2m
-Both antivirals & condom: .2% m2f risk, 1.2-1% risk f2m
-Does asymptomatic shedding factor into percent?
-Planned Parenthood states 75% asymptomatic shedding events last 1 day or less. you agree?
-WebMD states asymptomatic shedding happens 50% less than symptomatic- you agree?
-OHSV1 sheds “far more often” than GHSV1. Any sense of what far more often means?
-Can you only contract HSV-1 through shedding if there is contact with the inside of your mouth or genitals (as opposed to the thicker skin of the rest of the body)?
-What do you mean from your forum: “… transmission is volume related so simple shedding would not ensure transmission”?Thank you for your devotion to this work and care for us!!
-
June 7, 2021 at 7:37 am #73841Terri WarrenKeymaster
Does this math add up? Assuming no active infection
-If HSV-2 risk is 10% m2f, 4% f2m, HSV-1 risk lower (does this data assume outbreaks happen or asymptomatic?)
This data is based on clinical trials where we study discordant couples – that is, one has HSV 2 and one does not. And they have been together for a while before they enter a trial together, obviously. So in a sense, they are “survivors” of any transmission that might have happened early in the relationship
-HSV-2 on antivirals reduces risk by 50-70%, so at highest, 5% / 2% risk, at lowest, 3% / 1.2% risk
Yup
-HSV-2 with condoms reduces risk by 96% / 60-65%, so .4% m2f / 1.6-1.4% f2m
4%, not .4%
-Both antivirals & condom: .2% m2f risk, 1.2-1% risk f2m
Same correction
-Does asymptomatic shedding factor into percent?
that’s included, yes, as most transmission occur when someone has no symptoms
-Planned Parenthood states 75% asymptomatic shedding events last 1 day or less. you agree?
Yes
-WebMD states asymptomatic shedding happens 50% less than symptomatic- you agree?
People who have outbreaks shed virus on about 20% of days measured vs. those who simply test positive but have no symptoms who shed virus on about 10% of days.
-OHSV1 sheds “far more often” than GHSV1. Any sense of what far more often means?
People who have recurrent cold sores, about one every other month, shed virus on about 25% of days, this is not you. We don’t know your shedding rate because we don’t know if you are infected orally or genitally.
-Can you only contract HSV-1 through shedding if there is contact with the inside of your mouth or genitals (as opposed to the thicker skin of the rest of the body)?
Correct
-What do you mean from your forum: “… transmission is volume related so simple shedding would not ensure transmission”?
I think I meant that there are other factors in transmission besides viral shedding, and that it takes a certain amount of virus to infect someone else, not just ANY virus at all. The other factors in transmission relate to things like susceptible partner immune status, frequency of intercourse, whether condoms are used, whether antiviral therapy is used.TErri
-
June 23, 2021 at 6:52 pm #74027kindnessmattersParticipant
Thank you for your thorough response to my questions!
I am not sure if I need to pay again to ask these, if so, I’m happy to retroactively take care of that…just let me know!
A couple nitty gritty questions remain:
– can ohsv1 be transmitted via saliva while an asymptomatic shedding event is occurring orally? For example if using saliva (spit) as lube on my partner for a hand job- no contact with inside the mouth of infected, just saliva of infected used externally.
– can ghsv1 be spread via semen/ genital secretions, poop or blood? (For example, if infected is fingered by not infected, then not infected puts finger in their mouth/ touches their genitals)
– can antivirals be used on an as needed basis for sexual activity or do they need to be taken daily regardless of activity to be effective when needed? Not needed for ob in this case, just to minimize transmission from asymptomatic shedding events to partners.
That oughta do it for a while for me… so glad you are so committed to integral information on this stuff! Thank you again.
-
June 25, 2021 at 10:21 am #74046Terri WarrenKeymaster
– can ohsv1 be transmitted via saliva while an asymptomatic shedding event is occurring orally? For example if using saliva (spit) as lube on my partner for a hand job- no contact with inside the mouth of infected, just saliva of infected used externally.
I get that question often. That is extremely unlikely.– can ghsv1 be spread via semen/ genital secretions, poop or blood? (For example, if infected is fingered by not infected, then not infected puts finger in their mouth/ touches their genitals)
HSV 1 could be spread by genital secretions correct. Not the other. Herpes is not in blood except in very rare first infections– can antivirals be used on an as needed basis for sexual activity or do they need to be taken daily regardless of activity to be effective when needed? Not needed for ob in this case, just to minimize transmission from asymptomatic shedding events to partners.
If you wanted to use suppression to reduce transmission to a sex partner, you would need to start dosing 5 days in advance for the medicine to be fully effective.
Terri
-
June 28, 2021 at 6:48 pm #74074kindnessmattersParticipant
Thanks again, Terri!
I feel much more confident in figuring out how to talk with new partners about this from your straightforward and clear answers.
Thanks for creating this shared space so we can all learn from each other as well as you with up to date data 🙂
Well wishes…
-
July 8, 2021 at 4:02 pm #74135Terri WarrenKeymaster
You are most welcome
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.