› Forums › Herpes Questions › Old or new infection?
- This topic has 13 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 11 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
November 11, 2016 at 10:33 am #16008whathappenedSpectator
Hi Terri,
In April I suddenly had genital herpes symptoms, painless and no irritation but 6 or 7 sore like things on my penis that healed and went away in a couple weeks. At this point I had been with my partner for a few months.
Got tested swab and blood both negative although swab might be expected since it had already been a week and begun to heal. My previous partner had been over 8 months prior to the time of this test so I concluded it was either a new infection from the current partner or not herpes.4/19, Quest: HSV 2 IGG TYPE SPECIFIC AB <0.90index
Current partner is confident she is neg. due to a deficient immune system and never having symptoms, because of the length of time between my last relationship and my test she doesn’t get tested. 2 months later we split so I ask that she get tested to be sure. Her results were negative.
Over the course of the summer I had two more instances of symptoms all painless and irritation-less sores less extreme than the first and seem to be brought on by friction. Paranoid i go to my doc who says based on the timeline and negative results from me and the girl i had been dating I’ve nothing to worry about. I push for a test anyway..Positive!
9/6 LabCorps HSV 2 IGG TYPE SPECIFIC 9.23index
I have had no new sexual partners at this point. I ask my ex to get another test thinking she could have had a new infection herself back and had not yet produced antibodies the first time..again negative. She showed me both results so honesty is not an issue.
What are the chances and 8+ month old infection would be completely missed by a blood test?
Is it typical that a dormant infection could suddenly become symptomatic and recurrent?My research has shown that after 6months the test are very reliable and also that contracting herpes non sexually is next to impossible, but I don’t know what else to think. Should i get tested again? any idea how infection could have occurred?
Thanks
-
November 13, 2016 at 11:41 am #16027whathappenedSpectator
Also assuming it is a new infection, is there any real possibility i could have gotten it from her and she just doesn’t produce antibodies thus her negative results?
It would seem my options are
-8+ month old infection that wasn’t picked up by my first test and had just started to become symptomatic.
-New infection from partner but partner doesn’t produce antibodies
-Infection via some inexplicable non-sexual way -
November 13, 2016 at 3:22 pm #16055Terri WarrenKeymaster
So statistically, the most likely thing here is that the new partner is infected with HSV 2 and the test missed it. That’s the most likely since you had several sores and it took weeks to resolve. While it is possible that you could have been infected for 8 months and stayed negative, that probably isn’t what happened because now you are positive and the time frame fits the new partner far better. You did not acquire this in a non-sexual way.
Terri
-
November 13, 2016 at 3:49 pm #16058whathappenedSpectator
Hi Terri
The thing is she tested negative at 2 and 6 months after my first symptoms and negative test, maybe i didn’t explain that very well. Ive had no new partners since the partner in question. And before her my last partner was 8+ month prior to my symptoms and inital neg. result.
So either my first test missed an old infection which seems unlikely if you consider suddenly getting symptoms for the first time too. Or she doesn’t produce antibodies? or was she newly infected and still hasn’t seroconverted at 6 months??
-
November 13, 2016 at 3:52 pm #16059whathappenedSpectator
It seems odd her test would miss twice no?
-
November 14, 2016 at 9:19 am #16067Terri WarrenKeymaster
It’s all odd, for sure, but the most likely thing again is that her IgG test is missing her HSV 2 infection. The timing just makes more sense that way. compared to the western blot in our most recent study the IgG test misses 5-7% of infections. I mean, someone makes up that percentage. Obviously, I cannot be certain about this nor am I pointing any fingers, but to have new symptoms AND seroconvert and have it be an infection from 8 months prior with a negative test in between makes less sense – to me. In my experience, once a test misses an infection (and I’ve certainly seen it before, it continues to miss it). This is particularly true for HSV 1 but also happens with HSV 2.
This is your final post on this subscription – if you have more questions, feel free to renew
Terri
- This reply was modified 9 years, 11 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
November 14, 2016 at 11:49 am #16084whathappenedSpectator
Terri, thanks for helping me understand how things may have unfolded a little better.
Couple more questions:
Is the whole asymptomatic people vs. symptomatic people just a total crapshoot? In this case the person would have no overt symptoms but also has a compromised immune system, one would think someone with a crappy immune system would have it worse, thoughts based on your experience?
Also out of curiosity, does the test miss 5-7% of cases due to the effectiveness of the test method and general test error, or is it related to the nuances and complexities of different peoples immune response?
Thanks
-
November 14, 2016 at 2:03 pm #16088Terri WarrenKeymaster
Yes one would think if a person really did have a poor immune system they would be more likely to be symptomatic. What compromises her immune system?
We don’t know why the test misses some cases, surely do wish we did know that!
Terri
-
November 14, 2016 at 3:05 pm #16091whathappenedSpectator
Chronic Lyme. Is it possible to not have any outbreaks with a condition like that?
-
November 15, 2016 at 6:35 am #16097Terri WarrenKeymaster
Yes, it is possible.
I’m not going to come up with an answer for you and I doubt that you will either – it’s one of those things that just doesn’t make sense and the task now is to move on I think, do you agree?Terri
-
November 19, 2016 at 9:38 am #16166whathappenedSpectator
Thanks Terri,
It seems i was confused and accidentally made two accounts aswell 🙂 I’ll try and repeat my last post.
I get that there will be no conclusive answer, but learning about what possibly may have occurred is sorta cathartic and a little interesting tbh. It was difficult for me because how little sense my case made. It’s not about finding enough info to blame anyone, just reassuring myself that that we do in fact live in reality and wasn’t magically inflicted with herpes.
I had a question about the the 5-7% of people that could have a missed infection with IGG. You say they will typically miss again, does this mean its more of a per person statistic rather than a per single test statistic? Because i ultimately was able to seroconvert does that 5-7% really apply to my first negative test? Are there other reasons for a false neg if hypothetically it was a an old infection from my last partner 35 or so weeks ago. Have you have any knowledge of someone taking upwards of 9 month to show antibody?
-
November 20, 2016 at 4:21 pm #16170Terri WarrenKeymaster
Yes, to use your term, I think it is more of a per person statistic than a single test statistic.
I actually don’t think it does apply to you, at least in my experience, your situation doesn’t fit. I don’t know of anyone who has not taken rather extensive antiviral therapy who has taken 9 months to develop antibody. Do you know the status of the person 9 months ago?Terri
-
November 21, 2016 at 7:01 am #16176whathappenedSpectator
I don’t know their status, seemed too far back to feel appropriate to ask. It was however,a monogamous relationship between two healthy completely aysmpoymtic people who certainly didn’t think they had herpes! Whatever that’s worth. The 9 month date was the end of that realtionship. If it wasn’t from that partner we’d be looking at my infection occurring out past 3 years from initial symptoms and neg. test.
-
November 21, 2016 at 8:10 am #16178Terri WarrenKeymaster
Sorry, don’t know what else to tell you about this situation. I agree that it isn’t completely clear. One other option would be to re-test and be certain that there were no lab mix-ups.
This is your final post on this subscription. If you have more questions, feel free to renew.
Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.