› Forums › Herpes Questions › Valtrex not working
- This topic has 5 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 4 months ago by Terri Warren.
-
AuthorPosts
-
-
June 19, 2016 at 6:44 pm #13966reallysadaboutthisSpectator
I was recently diagnosed with HSV-2 and unfortunately, it appears that I am likely one of the individuals who will suffer more than most from this. I was diagnosed in March with a positive viral swab and I’ve already had about 8 outbreaks (although, they are so frequent that they all blend together so I’m uncertain of the number). My blood test was negative so this was most likely the first occurrence. I have a healthy immune system as far as I know and tested negative for HIV at the same time I tested positive for Herpes. The symptoms are not terribly severe but enough that they make sex nearly impossible. I have genital symptoms as well as symptoms on my legs and stomach. I have also had rashes on my chest, arms and pain in my left knee that I think may be related.
I was taking episodic valaclyovir and then quickly went on the suppressive dose of 1 gram a day. It seems to do nothing.
I’m hoping that you can provide me with some help in researching information about other treatment for managing this illness and what specialists I should be talking to for a hard to treat case like mine? While I know a cure is not possible, I need some help in developing a treatment regimen that will help me manage this disease and have a normal sex life. In particular, I’m wondering if surgery may be an option? I read that it was a treatment for the worst cases before the development of anti-virals, but have found nothing recent.
My trigger seems entirely based on sex. I have sex and then I’ll have an outbreak on one particular sore about an hour later. I have had an outbreak EVERY SINGLE TIME I have had sex since the diagnosis. My symptoms clear up. I have sex and then have symptoms for 5-7 days. I have tried lube and it doesn’t seem to help. This is why I want surgery. My main issue is this one, rather large and painful sore. If have not had an outbreak that was not triggered by friction on that one sore. Do you have any advice for how to have sex without causing an OB?
-
June 21, 2016 at 6:25 am #13974Terri WarrenKeymaster
There is absolutely no place in the disease management for surgery – what were you thinking would be managed surgically? If you were my patient, I would take you off suppression and ask you to swab the lesion that you get each time you have sex to be absolutely certain what you are having is a herpes outbreak. I have a patient who has documented HSV 2 by western blot and she reported a very similar situation. She was actually in a study and we had to swab her every time she had an outbreak. And she had them always after sex. Turns out she was never getting any virus from her swabbing because these were not herpes outbreaks – I think there were likely fissuring of the skin in the area she had had her original outbreak that thinned the skin and sex opened it up. So you might consider going back to square zero and see if this is herpes. The rashes all over your body are very unlikely to be related to herpes. Chest and arms are not in the same nerve group as the genitals. Again, if you really think these are herpes related, a swab test can confirm or deny that and we would definitely do that rather than jumping in with a new intervention, for example. The other thing that makes me curious is the lack of help from suppression. But then, if you do decide to swab, it won’t be a problem not taking it, it seems. It is not going to work to continue suppression AND swab because you won’t be able to separate out the effect of the medicines from the swab results.
Terri
-
June 22, 2016 at 7:38 pm #13989reallysadaboutthisSpectator
Hi Terri,
Thank you for your reply, but I think you missed the biggest part of the question: How do I research clinically supported alternatives if the valtrex is not working? It’s not working. Please believe me. I am in terrible misery. I CAN’T HAVE SEX without painful sores breaking out all over my thighs, genitals, pubis, butt, and legs. I show my partner that I love him through sex and that huge part of my life is gone. THE VALTREX IS NOT WORKING. Please take this seriously.
You seem skeptical that my OBs are being triggered by sex, but I strongly believe that they are. I had sex yesterday. About 45 minutes after sex I watched a red rash appear on my thighs, and pubis. Some of this then resolved into vesicles. I also developed the same large genital sore. I have never had these symptoms before my diagnosis of herpes which was confirmed via a viral swab. When I asked my current doctor for an alternative to valtrex she said, “the valtrex should work.” Her only other option was acupuncture, which I’ve seen no scientific support for. From you, I’m hoping to find alternatives that I can take to the new doctor I am looking for.
Questions: 1) What type of doctor might have experience with treating herpes when valtrex doesn’t work?
2) What alternative medications can I suggest that he or she research or consider trying?
3) Can you explain why surgery is not an option? As I put in my original post if my herpes is being triggered by friction would it be possible to excise those damaged cells? I know this wouldn’t cure me or manage my other symptoms, but it may possibly remove this most troubling symptom.
4) I think the sore is herpes. It’s the exact size, shape, and location of my original diagnosis which was confirmed with a viral swab. Can you please provide advice as if it were herpes?
5) Does it matter if I have sex when I have no genital symptoms if transmission is not a concern?
6) Should I be concerned that my immune system has been compromised?
-
June 24, 2016 at 10:52 am #14018Terri WarrenKeymaster
You can research antiviral alternatives at PubMed – it has many publications about the science of herpes and you may find something there.
i thought long and hard about your question and gave you my best thoughts about this but you seem to be on a different track and feel strongly that you know exactly what is going on, and you could be right. But I’m a scientist – I check out impressions before acting on them. And I have never ever seen a herpes outbreak triggered by sex start within 45 minutes – you may well be the first.
What would you surgically remove? This virus lives in the group of nerves that supplies sensation and function to the area from your waist to mid thigh.
You may wish to see an infectious disease physician as a specialist.
If you look at some of the herpes research online, you will find alternative treatments. I don’t use any because none has been proven to be effective but you could certainly try some.
Terri
-
June 24, 2016 at 4:46 pm #14027reallysadaboutthisSpectator
I know you’re a scientist and have many years of experience. That’s why I came to you for advice, when I was told to go to an acupuncturist, because I don’t believe that is clinically supported. Like you, I believe in empirical evidence and all can say as a person with no medical training is what I observe. The rash comes around the areas where I’ve had vesicles before. I will begin to keep a diary what time after sex I begin to see symptoms (if I see them at all). I have stopped taking the valtrex and the next time I get that sore I will have it tested per your advice. Then I will write you back and then we will know which one of us is right. I will follow through on this whether or not I am right or wrong.
When I asked for alternative medications, I didn’t mean alternative medicine like quacks. I just wanted the names of different medicines that I can go to Pub Med and search for.
1) What scientifically and clinically supported medications and treatments are there? I’m asking your advice as a scientist. You’ve said there are other interventions that are possible. What are they? Do you recommend them? If you give me the names then I can go on PubMed and research them.
2) What treatment option would you pursue if a patient was not responding to valtrex?
3) I would just like to cut out the damaged cells so that hopefully I wouldn’t get a sore in that spot any more. Regardless of what’s causing it, it’s very painful and makes sex nearly impossible. I’m just wondering why this wouldn’t be possible. I know it’s radical but this is horrible, and I’m just exploring my possibilities.
4) Please answer questions, 4, 5, 6 above. (especially 5).
-
June 27, 2016 at 8:46 pm #14072Terri WarrenKeymaster
I’m not saying you aren’t correct but I am saying that it would be best to have that opinion confirmed so we can be sure about what you’re dealing with. There’s no right or wrong here, it’s always just best to confirm.
The three scientifically proven treatments for herpes, that are currently available for purchase, are acyclovir, valacyclovir and famciclovir. Some people find other things helpful like Lysine but the science doesn’t support that, in a metanalysis.
I probably would try Famvir
It wouldn’t be possible to cut out the area because if you do the virus will just travel to a new location and occur there. Don’t feel badly – many people have asked that, but because the whole nerve group is infected, surgery would not fix the problem
If you have no symptoms and your partner is uninfected, you can still possibly transmit
whether or not your immune system is compromised would be an issue to take up with your PCP – that would be pretty easy to assess, I feel.
You know my opinion about #4
This is your final post on this subscription – if you have more questions feel free to renew.Terri
-
-
AuthorPosts
You must register to ask your own question or be logged in to reply to this question.