› Forums › Herpes Questions › Discordant HSV-2 test results. › Reply To: Discordant HSV-2 test results.
You’re right – herpes testing is not perfect but I think we know how to manage it more successfully than we used to.
In the case you describe, I believe there is an error somewhere along the line – either a mislabeling by the person drawing the blood or a mix up somewhere in the lab itself. She could repeat the IgG with LabCorp and see what happens with a new sample or she could do the blot, which is highly sensitive (>99) for HSV 2 if she is still worried. She knows if she’s a virgin or not, really, and if she knows that she is then there is no way she could have HSV 2 unless acquired at birth or through molestation.
There is no normal variability in testing that would account for this enormous swing in index values
Seroreversion has no place in this particular discussion.
So I think the model for herpes testing should be IgG screening 12 weeks after possible infection, if the index value is between 1.1 and 3.5, western blot confirmation. If the index value is higher, less than 5, and the person has had no symptoms nor any reason to really suspect they have herpes, it can also be reference to western blot. I have had a few people test positive on the IgG test with index values between 3.5 and 5 that were negative by western blot.
Terri