› Forums › Herpes Questions › Discouraged and questioning › Reply To: Discouraged and questioning
1) Do you have any advice? Think the Western Blot is worth it?
I see nothing whatsoever controversy all about CDC recommendation. I wonder what guidance she uses to determine the best treatment for syphilis or for HIV or for gonorrhea or for chlamydia? The CDC is actually quite conservative in its recommendations and when it recommends something I follow it as should she. Her statement that this is a controversial recommendation makes no sense what so ever to me. How incredibly annoying.
2) What causes a false positive, anyway?
False positives are most commonly caused by people having a protein in their blood that is a similar molecular weight to one of the proteins associated with HSV-2 antibody. It artificially trips the IgG test and makes a Western blot sometimes look indeterminate. We can almost always sort it out the answer to whether you are infected or not by using the Western blot, the best tool available. By the way, the Western blot test itself is in no way controversial. The technique was used for many years to confirm positive HIV test, and is now used most commonly to confirm questionable herpes test results. It is not a test for a specific disease state, it is a method of looking for protein bands.
3) If I do a video conference, would you be willing to order the western blot? I have an AnyLabTestNow an hour away.
I would be happy to order the Western blot for you via the video conference method. We can do these tests as part of a research study we are doing to compare the accuracy of IgG to the Western blot gold standard.
Sometimes I wonder if clinicians tell people the Western blot is controversial because they are simply unfamiliar with the test or with the CDC guidelines. What do you think?
Terri