› Forums › Herpes Questions › Clarifying GHSV1 stats › Reply To: Clarifying GHSV1 stats
1. I can try to find the comments, but they don’t cite evidence, so I don’t think they’re that meaningful except as evidence that views on this point are not uniform. More importantly, this is not about proving a negative. It’s about estimating the rate at which one who already has OHSV1 contracts GHSV1. It should be possible (in principle) to find a class of people who shed HSV1 only orally and then measure what fraction of them later in life begin shedding HSV1 genitally upon exposure.
That research has not been done
2. I suggest you not cite the 2% stat without being very clear that this is 2+ years out. Otherwise, it seems highly misleading.
If you look above, I do cite the 2+ years out, and it isn’t 2%, it is 1.3%
4. FWIW, partner immunity shouldn’t factor in here. One’s contagion risk can be calculated independent of any partner-specific factors, which should be an independent variable.
It really isn’t quite that simple as we don’t know all of the factors involved in transmission. For example, we know that antivirals reduce shedding by around 70% but transmission by only by only 48%. Something is going on there but we just don’t know all the factors involved in transmission or lack of transmission. So I would respectfully disagree that partner specific factors don’t play a role in calculating transmission.
5. You misunderstand me. Assume 50% of the population has OHSV1, 10% of the population has GHSV1, 20% of the people with GHSV1 also have OHSV1 (because they got them at the same time), and OHSV1 is 13x more contagious than GHSV1 (based on viral shedding rates). Now imagine two sexual partners: person A has GHSV1 and person B does not (and has no clue about OHSV1). Person B is 1.8x more likely to give you GHSV1 (assuming oral and genital sex) than person A. If true, that would be extremely important: A GHSV1 diagnosis actually makes you SAFER!!
Safer from what?
6. First off, the 1.3% stat is for people 2+ years out. You really need to make that explicit. But even assuming that, if a partner is contagious 4 days a year and people have sex 2x/week, then there’s a 28% chance of sex on each of those 4 days, meaning a 63% chance of having sex on a viral shedding day during the first year and an 86% chance after 2 years.
An 86% chance of having intercourse on a shedding day after the second year, when a person is shedding only 4 days a year? I’m sorry but that doesn’t make sense to me.
Terri