› Forums › Herpes Questions › Ethical Obligation to Test Further? (Female with New Male Partner) › Reply To: Ethical Obligation to Test Further? (Female with New Male Partner)
If I get the test and am positive, I will have chosen to make my life painful. There are so many unaware HSV+ ppl dating without restriction, and I will have martyred myself because of a compulsive need for reassurance. Drs seem to think I’ve done my due diligence. My partner tested neg. I had 5 gynecological exams in 3 months and nothing looked herpetic. No med professional has actively advised further testing, except for “peace of mind” (this is the phrase the dr who gave me the IgM used, since he was so sure I’d be neg, so I don’t find this convincing). The test is not part of standard screenings, so most asymptomatic people don’t know they have it. If I am HSV1+ (probably my greatest risk) I wouldn’t know where it is. I’d have to tell men, “I have this highly stigmatized, contagious virus. I don’t know where it is, and I don’t have obvious symptoms, but I could give it to you.” If a man rejected me after that, it wouldn’t mean he’s cruel or unreasonable – especially because it would have to take place before he invested significantly in our relationship. He knows he probably won’t be with me forever, so he might need make the disclosure to his next girlfriend, and ruin the spontaneity and excitement of a new relationship. Of course, he or his next girlfriend could have HSV, but they won’t get tested so they’ll never know. And he’d probably rather be with a partner who might have a disease than one who definitely has it – which is understandable.
I’m not saying HSV+ people always get rejected. However, polls have shown that most people would reject a partner for having herpes, and optimistic individual case studies don’t make that fact any easier: if I had brown eyes and brown eyes were stigmatized, I wouldn’t think I was dirty for having them and I wouldn’t think the stigma was justified, but I would do anything to change the fact that I had them. Even if my partner looked past my herpes, I’d always worry that I was infecting him – without symptoms, how could I maximize safety? The other option would be to get into some HSV+ dating group. I’m sure there are wonderful people in these groups, but it’s so painful to know that my dating pool is that severely restricted – especially since women are often more prone to this than men. Finally, rather than checking my genitals 10x/day, I’d check them 20 – searching obsessively for any sign of a breakout (because at least I’d know that’s where I have it). I don’t want to be old, lonely and anxious: hating the young me for giving myself an unfair burden when, absent symptoms, it wasn’t necessary.
On the other hand, a neg test result would give me so much relief. When I start a new relationship, I’ll feel guilty that I made the choice to stop testing. I’ll feel like I’m hiding the genital pain and positive IgMs from future partners. I’ll still feel like I have to inspect myself constantly. And what if I pass it on to someone and he gets symptoms? Could I truly tell him I didn’t know I had it?