Your labs for HSV 2 are truly all over the place! I don’t recall having seen such discrepant HSV 2 results like this in anyone. I would certainly recommend a western blot for you for clarity.
In terms of your baby: If your baby had acquired HSV 2 from you at birth, she would have been sick – usually pretty damn sick and in the hospital. Was that the case?
Also, at 1.35, if we had that value alone, with no 7.25, there would have been an 85% chance that this is a false positive. Very weird.